To think John Pinner used to be just that guy who buys insurance at Mattel Inc. Not anymore.
Since Sept. 11, Pinner, risk manager and assistant treasurer at the El Segundo,
Calif.-based $5-billion toy maker, is now approaching celebrity status
Recommended For You
least he finds himself on the carpet in CFO Kevin Farr's office quite
regularly. There, he tries to explain the impact of the disaster on the
insurance markets and why, after so many years of bargain basement premiums,
insurance now costs more for less. I'm
in the spotlight now, says Pinner, and
it isn't a very nice light.
Of course, he's only half-kidding about his 15
minutes of fame. These days the lives of corporate risk managers across the
nation are really beginning to live up to their title. I've never seen a hard market like the one we have now,
Pinner says. In some cases, we're
not talking double-digit increases, we're talking triple-digit increases.
And all this comes at a time when companies are
feeling the teeth of the current recession. [Farr's]
got great pressure on him to reduce the bottom line and expects all of us to cut
our budgets, Pinner explains. Even
though he reads in the papers every day that the insurance market is chaotic,
coming in with a budget that is up 50% doesn't make him a happy man. Insurance
is something, given all his operational responsibilities, that he really
doesn't want to have to think about.
Reverse of the '90s
Unfortunately, Farr and his fellow CFOs don't
have that luxury anymore. Neither do the foot soldiers like Pinner who must go
out and negotiate the best deals they can for their companies.Fortunately,
Pinner says, he never tried to take credit for the soft insurance market of the
1990s as other risk managers did. I
made sure I told our treasurer Bill Stavro that insurance is a market, and the
low prices would someday be followed by higher prices, he explains. But Pinner
has to admit he never expected the spike, when it finally hit, to be so extreme.
Fellow risk managers also bemoan their sudden
notoriety. I used to have a pretty
easy job, says Sewell Mechem, insurance and risk manager at SEI Investments Co.,
an Oaks, Pa.-based global provider of asset management and investment technology
solutions with $600 million in annual revenues. I
report to the chief legal counsel and, every year, I would tell him my budget
was either equal to or 10% less than it was the year before. He liked me. He'd
say, OECome on in.'
Those days are gone. I recently had to write up a report for my boss explaining why
our premiums were increasing, even though we were retaining more risk
internally, Mechem explains. There
wasn't much he could say. But he listened intently.
Prior to August 2001, Mechem had a three-year
professional-liability insurance policy with CNA Insurance Cos. in Evanston,
Ill. The insurance is critical to SEI, protecting it against lawsuits alleging
professional malpractice. When the policy expired one month before the terrorist
attacks, Mechem tried to extend it another year
interested in a long-term deal. And
this was before Sept. 11, she sighs. The
best deal I could negotiate was a single-year policy, with a much higher
deductible and co-insurance element.
Greater Appreciation
Excess of SEI's deductible, the company pays
20% of the loss and the insurer 80%, up to a certain limit of liability, which
Mechem is not at liberty to disclose. Even with all this extra risk on the
company's books, SEI is still paying about 35% more for the insurance,
although Mechem says it is difficult to compare the single-year deal to the
previous three-year program. This
is a very complicated insurance policy we have put together, given the sliding
deductible and the co-insurance, she notes.
The current level of sophistication required in
most insurance deals explains why, despite the bad news they keep delivering,
skilled risk managers are appreciated more than ever.
Next up for Mechem, for instance, are
negotiations on the company's property insurance policy, which expires in
April. From what I've been
hearing and reading, our premiums are more than likely to double, she says. So
she is exploring alternative risk transfer mechanisms, including possibly
forming a wholly owned captive insurance company. Says Mechem: To just sit around and absorb higher costs and greater risk is
not doing my job.
© Touchpoint Markets, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more inforrmation visit Asset & Logo Licensing.